---
title: "Old Pelican Bay - Fort Myers Real Estate"
url: https://stacklist.com/card/bc313918-8bf4-4223-8212-b55a6c8aaadb
source_url: "https://www.greaterftmyers.com/old-pelican-bay/"
stack: https://stacklist.com/c/places/stack/47bc3d88-b5ae-41d9-9945-0824d19ae378
summary: "Old Pelican Bay is a gated waterfront neighborhood in Fort Myers Beach offering canal access, boat docks, and a five-minute route to open Gulf waters. The community features single-family homes, townhomes, and condos developed from the late 1980s through 2007, with current listings around $1.1 million median price."
tags: "real-estate, waterfront, boating, fort-myers-beach, gated-community, gulf-access, florida"
key_entities: "Old Pelican Bay (location), Fort Myers Beach (location), Gulf of Mexico (location), Sanibel Island (location), Premiere Plus Realty Co. (organization), Era Lahaina Realty (organization), Bonita Springs (location), Mark Washburn (person)"
classification: "reference"
content_hash: "sha256:93b9a6a73e25515fa6f277ca5f8e932712989e262748a0966c668dc0f0d21f5f"
acp_version: "0.2"
token_counts_approximate: 861
visibility: public
agent_accessible: true
status: "final"
---

# Old Pelican Bay - Fort Myers Real Estate

Home Fort Myers Beach Old Pelican Bay Old Pelican Bay Real Estate Old Pelican Bay is a gated waterfront neighborhood tucked away in Fort Myers Beach , bordering canals and mangroves. Ideal for boaters with its easy access to the Gulf, residents can reach open water in 5 minutes by boat. Homes include a mix of single-family residences, townhomes, and condos, all designed to take advantage of the views and waterfront setting. The area was developed starting in the late 1980s with properties still under construction through 2007. Many of the homes are generous in size with multiple bedrooms, indoor/outdoor living spaces and private pools as well as boat docks and electric lifts. HOA fees are relatively low but reflect access to the many boating amenities and security.  Apart from its Gulf access, Old Pelican Bay is close to the Sanibel Island Causeway and the area’s pristine beaches as well as near Peppertree Pointe and Port Sanibel Marinas for additional boating and watersports. Shopping and dining along McGregor Boulevard and in the nearby San Carlos/Iona corridor are also a short drive away. Old Pelican Bay Homes For Sale Old Pelican Bay Homes For Sale July 27, 2026 2 Listed 74 Avg. DOM $427.54 Avg. $ / Sq.Ft. $1,122,495 Med. List Price Gallery Photo View List Map Map View Get Alerts! Refine Results Best Match Price (Highest) Price (Lowest) Days on Site (Newest) Days on Site (Oldest) Bedrooms (Most) 2 Properties $1,275,000 50 12205 Siesta Dr Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931 Old Pelican Bay 3 Beds 3 Baths 2,367 Sq.Ft. Era Lahaina Realty $969,990 49 12220 Siesta Dr Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931 Old Pelican Bay 3 Beds 3 F 1 1/2 Baths 2,884 Sq.Ft. Premiere Plus Realty Company Old Pelican Bay Homes Recent Sales 1 Property Address Beds Baths Sq.Ft. List Price Sold Price $/Sq.Ft. Sold Date 18141 Old Pelican Bay Dr Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931 5 4 3,590 $1,399,000 $1,150,000 $320.33 3/11/26 Explore Fort Myers Beach Real Estate... Homes Condos Boating Communities New Construction New Listings Pool Homes Pet-friendly Condos Luxury Homes Estero Boulevard We're Here to Help Feel free to reach out any time: Greater Fort Myers Team Premiere Plus Realty Co. 3409 Pelican Landing Pkwy #1B Bonita Springs, FL 34134 O: (239) 464-9929 M: (239) 464-9929 E: Email Us Connect Facebook Have a Question or Want a Free Market Report? Contact Us Home Blog Search Advanced Search Search by Map Property Tracker Featured Listings Communities Babcock Ranch Cape Coral Estero Fort Myers Beach North Fort Myers Sanibel Bonita Springs Captiva Fort Myers Naples Pine Island Buying Buying Why Work With Us? Home Finder Mortgage Calculator Our Guarantee International Buyers How To Use This Website Florida Tax Advantage Establishing Florida Residency Selling Selling Closing Costs Get More Buyers Feature Your Home Leverage Blogging Value Your Home Sales Process Sold Properties Instant Valuations About About Us Testimonials Contact Questions? We're Here to Help Recently From Our Blog Caloosa Creek Offers Spacious Homes in Prime Fort Myers Location By Mark Washburn 7/27/2026 Inside Luxury Beachfront Living at Gulfside Twelve By Mark Washburn 7/20/2026 We're Here to Help Feel free to reach out any time: Greater Fort Myers Team Premiere Plus Realty Co. 3409 Pelican Landing Pkwy #1B Bonita Springs, FL 34134 O: (239) 464-9929 M: (239) 464-9929 E: Email Us Connect Facebook Have a Question or Want a Free Market Report? Contact Us